At the funeral of a once popular teacher, Gene Waite, Kathryn Bogert is stunned when his distraught daughter Lizzie accuses her mother Mary of murdering him. It's true that the retired teacher turned flea market merchant had died mysteriously, but was he really murdered?

When the widow hires Kathryn to sell her husband's merchandise, Detective T. Cole discourages Kathryn's nosy meddling. Meanwhile, Kathryn discovers that Gene may have stumbled upon a valuable collection of the fourth edition of a popular cuddly toy, the Fuzzy Wuzzy, and in doing so, attracted the attention of a mysterious stranger who starts to shadow Kathryn's every move in a red Pinto. But Kathryn's intuitive powers have matured and she convinces Detective Cole that her investigation can net results. Now, can she actually solve the murder?